Thread by Thomas C. Theiner
Thread
The sound of russian ammo blowing up in Donetsk.
What does this mean for russian logistics?
A thread 🧵:
Since 2014-15 russia built dozens of ammo dumps hidden in civilian buildings near railway stations in the parts of Ukraine it occupies.
1/n
What does this mean for russian logistics?
A thread 🧵:
Since 2014-15 russia built dozens of ammo dumps hidden in civilian buildings near railway stations in the parts of Ukraine it occupies.
1/n
russian logistics depots are always close to railways as russia's military has a serious lack of logistic units, especially transport units.
This is compounded by russia's military being corrupt and technologically backwards, even eschewing things like forklifts or cranes.
2/n
This is compounded by russia's military being corrupt and technologically backwards, even eschewing things like forklifts or cranes.
2/n
So russian supplies and ammo are loaded by hand onto trains, transported towards the front, unloaded there by hand, loaded onto trucks by hand, and then driven to the frontline units, where it is unloaded again by hand.
It's time consuming. No other army is so backwards.
3/n
It's time consuming. No other army is so backwards.
3/n
So how did russian ammo supply in Donbas work until Ukraine received M142 HIMARS with long-range GMLRS rockets and highly accurate PzH 2000, AHS Krab, and CAESAR self-propelled howitzers?
Well:
1) in russia 2,000 to 4,000 of tons of ammo were loaded onto a train
4/n
Well:
1) in russia 2,000 to 4,000 of tons of ammo were loaded onto a train
4/n
2) the train entered Ukraine, stopped at various points 30-40 km from the front, ammo was unloaded and stored nearby
3) then frontline units sent their trucks to pick up the ammo they needed
The same applied for fuel, spares, food, etc.
5/n
3) then frontline units sent their trucks to pick up the ammo they needed
The same applied for fuel, spares, food, etc.
5/n
So dependent are the russians on railways that they have 28,500 railway troops tasked with repairing and building railways.
Like i.e. this bridge they built over the Oskil river to supply their planned upcoming offensive from Izium towards Sloviansk.
6/n
Like i.e. this bridge they built over the Oskil river to supply their planned upcoming offensive from Izium towards Sloviansk.
6/n
When russia's military can't access railways then its entire logistics system collapses.
The russian advance East of Kyiv failed when the russians couldn't capture the railways passing through Chernihiv and Sumy oblasts. With cities like Nizhyn, Chernihiv and Sumy stubbornly
7/n
The russian advance East of Kyiv failed when the russians couldn't capture the railways passing through Chernihiv and Sumy oblasts. With cities like Nizhyn, Chernihiv and Sumy stubbornly
7/n
defended by Ukrainian troops, russia had to truck its supplies to its troops East of Kyiv... and that failed spectacularly, as russian troops can't move more than 90-100 km from their supply depots and at that range russia can only supply its units for defensive operations.
8/n
8/n
The distance from railways in russia to Brovary outside Kyiv is 350 km... 300 km of which were swarming with Ukrainian special forces and partisans looking to blow up russian supply columns (photo).
Now in Donbas, Kherson, Zaporizhzhia russia can supply its troops by train.
9/n
Now in Donbas, Kherson, Zaporizhzhia russia can supply its troops by train.
9/n
This allows russia to bring forward the 10,000s of tons of artillery ammo it expends every week; and send the replacement tanks, howitzers, etc. needed to replace russia's immense material losses, and the needed fuel.
But now the russian ammo depots and supply points
10/n
But now the russian ammo depots and supply points
10/n
are within range of artillery and rockets.
AHS Krab, PzH 2000, and CAESAR can use base bleed projectiles with 40 km range (photo: a CAESAR firing a base bleed projectile).
Furthermore these howitzers' use modern fire control systems, which use GPS to establish their own
11/n
AHS Krab, PzH 2000, and CAESAR can use base bleed projectiles with 40 km range (photo: a CAESAR firing a base bleed projectile).
Furthermore these howitzers' use modern fire control systems, which use GPS to establish their own
11/n
position and then use the target's GPS coordinates to calculate the correct elevation and deflection of the barrel, then automatically move the barrel into position. All three systems also use radar to measure a fired projectile's speed & adjust the barrel after each shot.
12/n
12/n
Never before had Ukraine artillery with such accuracy and such range. This allows Ukraine to hit russian supply depots up to 35 km behind the front with pinpoint accuracy.
And thanks to 10,000s of Ukrainian patriots in the russian occupied territories Ukraine knows the
13/n
And thanks to 10,000s of Ukrainian patriots in the russian occupied territories Ukraine knows the
13/n
coordinates of EVERY russian ammo depot.
And now Ukraine also received GMLRS. GMLRS retains full accuracy up to 85 km. This allows Ukraine to land a rocket precisely onto a building 85 km away and set the fuze to detonate the 50 pounds of PBX-109 inside the building.
14/n
And now Ukraine also received GMLRS. GMLRS retains full accuracy up to 85 km. This allows Ukraine to land a rocket precisely onto a building 85 km away and set the fuze to detonate the 50 pounds of PBX-109 inside the building.
14/n
And if it is a large target (i.e. a warehouse) then Ukraine can hit it even if it is further away then 85 km.
These two new artillery capabilities have two effects:
1) russia is right now losing 1,000s of tons of ammo
2) russia can't store ammo within 100 km of the front
15/n
These two new artillery capabilities have two effects:
1) russia is right now losing 1,000s of tons of ammo
2) russia can't store ammo within 100 km of the front
15/n
Every destroyed depot reduces the ammo available to russia's massive number of artillery systems at the front. And russia has to replace this lost ammo. First it can't produce as much as it uses and loses, so russia is already shipping old Soviet ammo from Belarus to Donbas.
16/n
16/n
Secondly russia can't bring this ammo within range of Ukrainian artillery and GMLRS... and has to stop the trains now 90-100 km away from the front or else the ammo dump and train will be destroyed by Ukrainian artillery.
Ammo and supplies 100 km from the front means
17/n
Ammo and supplies 100 km from the front means
17/n
that russia again has to rely on trucks to supply its frontline units.
But russia already lost at least 1,200+ of its truck fleet and the remainder has been in use for months now - and russia's famous lack of maintenance is surely taking a huge toll on the remaining trucks.
18/n
But russia already lost at least 1,200+ of its truck fleet and the remainder has been in use for months now - and russia's famous lack of maintenance is surely taking a huge toll on the remaining trucks.
18/n
So how will russian logistics "work" now?
1) trains will stop 100 km from the front and ammo will be unloaded by hand
2) trucks will be loaded by hand and then drive to the front. Loading by hand takes hours and driving 100 km in a rear combat zone takes more hours
19/n
1) trains will stop 100 km from the front and ammo will be unloaded by hand
2) trucks will be loaded by hand and then drive to the front. Loading by hand takes hours and driving 100 km in a rear combat zone takes more hours
19/n
Worse for russia - russian trucks carry less tonnage then Western military trucks and unlike Western ammo russian ammo comes in bulky wooden boxes.
• russian ammo trucks transport mostly wood
• Western ammo trucks (photo) transport almost only bang🔥
20/n
• russian ammo trucks transport mostly wood
• Western ammo trucks (photo) transport almost only bang🔥
20/n
3) the russian trucks finally arrive at the front
4) the ammo is unloaded (by hand)
5) the trucks return to the railheads
At this distance russian truckers will struggle to make more than one supply run per day... and if the russians don't plan their supply runs perfectly
21/n
4) the ammo is unloaded (by hand)
5) the trucks return to the railheads
At this distance russian truckers will struggle to make more than one supply run per day... and if the russians don't plan their supply runs perfectly
21/n
then some units will get too little ammo, others too much - which is worse: because what do you with the extra ammo? Drop it on the ground or have the trucks stay with the unit until the ammo is needed?
If you drop it on the ground and the unit has to move... well then the
22/n
If you drop it on the ground and the unit has to move... well then the
22/n
ammo is lost. If you keep the trucks with the unit, then no one is driving back to get more ammo.
And while NATO armies use software and AI to plan their supply runs, russians use officers' guts... this wouldn't matter if russia had enough trucks, but having lost so many
23/n
And while NATO armies use software and AI to plan their supply runs, russians use officers' guts... this wouldn't matter if russia had enough trucks, but having lost so many
23/n
trucks of the already few ones it began the war with russia is now even less capable to supply units 100 km from railways.
russia is a 20th century military with 19th century logistics... and now it is fighting an army receiving 21st century weapons.
It will take time, but
24/n
russia is a 20th century military with 19th century logistics... and now it is fighting an army receiving 21st century weapons.
It will take time, but
24/n
while NLAW, Javelin and Stinger helped Ukraine win the Battle of Kyiv; now CAESAR, AHS Krab, PzH 2000 and especially GMLRS will help Ukraine win the Battle for Donbas and the Battle for Kherson.
Because: Amateurs talk strategy. Professionals talk logistics.
25/.
Because: Amateurs talk strategy. Professionals talk logistics.
25/.
While doing this thread @TrentTelenko did a russian logistics thread too :-)
Understandably - Ukraine wrecking russia's already wobbly logistics is what we will hear about a lot in the coming weeks and months.
Check out his thread too:
Understandably - Ukraine wrecking russia's already wobbly logistics is what we will hear about a lot in the coming weeks and months.
Check out his thread too:
