
Download the free Kindle app and start reading Kindle books instantly on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required.
Read instantly on your browser with Kindle for Web.
Using your mobile phone camera - scan the code below and download the Kindle app.
Ship of Magic (The Liveship Traders, Book 1) Mass Market Paperback – February 2, 1999
Bingtown is a hub of exotic trade and home to a merchant nobility famed for its liveships—rare vessels carved from wizardwood, which ripens magically into sentient awareness. Now the fortunes of one of Bingtown’s oldest families rest on the newly awakened liveship Vivacia.
For Althea Vestrit, the ship is her rightful legacy. For Althea’s young nephew, wrenched from his religious studies and forced to serve aboard the Vivacia, the ship is a life sentence. But the fate of the ship—and the Vestrits—may ultimately lie in the hands of an outsider: the ruthless buccaneer captain Kennit, who plans to seize power over the Pirate Isles by capturing a liveship and bending it to his will.
Don’t miss the magic of the Liveship Traders Trilogy:
SHIP OF MAGIC • MAD SHIP • SHIP OF DESTINY
- Print length832 pages
- LanguageEnglish
- PublisherSpectra
- Publication dateFebruary 2, 1999
- Dimensions4.2 x 1.25 x 6.85 inches
- ISBN-100553575635
- ISBN-13978-0553575637
Book recommendations, author interviews, editors' picks, and more. Read it now.
Frequently purchased items with fast delivery
- ‘One must plan for the future and anticipate the future without fearing the future.’Highlighted by 1,039 Kindle readers
- Forgiving the Day. Even the youngest child could do this; all it required was looking back over the day and dismissing the day’s pains as a thing that were past while choosing to remember as gains lessons learned or moments of insight.Highlighted by 853 Kindle readers
- “It is the nature of humans that we tend to pass our pain along. As if we could get rid of it by inflicting an equal hurt on someone else.”Highlighted by 453 Kindle readers
Editorial Reviews
Review
“Hobb gives us her usual marvelously coherent setting and intriguing, multidimensional characters who refuse to be pigeonholed.”—Publishers Weekly
“The characterizations are consistently superb, and [Hobb] animates everything with love for and knowledge of the sea. . . . Kudos to the author, and encore!” —Booklist
From the Inside Flap
For Althea Vestrit, the ship is her rightful legacy unjustly denied her--a legacy she will risk anything to reclaim. For Althea's young nephew Wintrow, wrenched from his religious studies and forced to serve aboard ship, Vivacia is a life sentence.
But the fate of the Vestrit family--and the ship--may ultimately lie in the hands of an outsider. The ruthless pirate Kennit seeks a way to seize power over all the denizens of the Pirate Isles...and the first step of his plan requires him to capture his own liveship and bend it to his will....
From the Back Cover
--Booklist
About the Author
Excerpt. © Reprinted by permission. All rights reserved.
"Mistress Althea." She had no more than gained the deck before Mild confronted her. "Cap'n requires you." The ship's boy grinned at her, half-apologetic, half-relishing being the bearer of such tidings.
"Very well, Mild," she said quietly. Very well, her thoughts echoed to herself. No wash, no clean clothes and no nap before the confrontation. Very well. She took a moment to smooth her hair back from her face and to tuck her blouse back into her trousers. Prior to her task, they had been her cleanest work clothes. Now the coarse cotton of the blouse stuck to her back and neck with her own sweat, while the trousers were smudged with oakum and tar from working in the close quarters of the hold. She knew her face was dirty, too. Well. She hoped Kyle would enjoy his advantage. She stooped down as if to re-fasten her shoe, but instead placed her hand flat on the wood of the deck. For an instant she closed her eyes and let the strength of the Vivacia flow through her palm. "Oh, ship," she whispered as softly as if she prayed. "Help me stand up to him." Then she stood, her resolve firm once more.
As she crossed the twilit deck to the captain's quarters, not an eye would meet hers. Every hand was suddenly very busy or simply looking off in another direction. She refused to glance back to see if they watched after her. Instead she kept her shoulders squared and her head up as she marched to her doom.
She rapped sharply at the door of the captain's quarters and waited for his gruff reply. When it came she entered, and then stood still, letting her eyes adjust to the yellow lantern light. In that instant, she felt a sudden wash of homesickness. The intense longing was not for any shoreside house, but rather for this room as it once had been. Memories dizzied her. Her father's oilskins had hung on that hook, and the smell of his favorite rum had flavored the air. Her own hammock he had rigged in that corner when he had first allowed her to start living aboard the Vivacia, that he might better watch over her. She knew a moment of anger as her eyes took in Kyle's clutter overlaying the familiar hominess of these quarters. A nail in his boot had left a pattern of scars across the polished floorboards. Ephron Vestrit had never left charts out, and would never have tolerated the soiled shirt flung across the chair back. He did not approve of an untidy deck anywhere on his ship, and that included his own quarters. His son-in-law Kyle apparently did not share those values.
Althea pointedly stepped over a discarded pair of trousers to stand before the captain at his table. Kyle let her stand there for a few moments while he continued to peruse some notation on the chart. A notation in her father's own precise hand, Althea noticed, and took strength from that even as her anger burned at the thought that he had access to the family's charts. A Trader family's charts were among their most guarded possessions. How else could one safeguard one's swiftest routes through the Inside Passage, and one's trading ports in lesser-known villages? Still, her father had entrusted these charts to Kyle; it was not up to her to question his decision.
Kyle continued to ignore her, but she refused to rise to his bait. She stood silent and patient, but did not let his apparent disinterest fluster her. After a time he lifted his eyes to regard her. Their blueness was as unlike her father's steady black eyes as his unruly blond hair was unlike her father's smooth black queue. Once more she wondered with distaste what had ever possessed her older sister to desire such a man. His Chalcedean blood showed in his ways as much as in his body. She tried to keep her disdain from showing on her face, but her control was wearing thin. She'd been too long at sea with this man.
This last voyage had been interminable. Kyle had muddled what should have been a simple two-month turnaround trip along Chalced's coast into a five-month trading trek full of unnecessary stops and marginally profitable trade runs. She was convinced all of it was an effort on his part to show her father what a sly trader he could be. For herself, she had not been impressed. At Tusk he had stopped and taken on pickled sea-duck eggs, always an uncertain cargo, and barely made dock in Brigtown in time to sell them off before they went rotten. In Brigtown, he'd taken on bales of cotton, not just enough to fill the empty space in the holds but enough to make a partial deck load as well. Althea had had to bite her tongue and watch her crew take their chances as they scrambled over and around the heavy bales, and then they'd had a late gale that had soaked and most likely ruined the portion of the load on deck. She hadn't even asked him what the profit had been, if any, when he'd stopped to auction it off in Dursay. Dursay had been their last port. The wine casks had yet again been shifted about to allow for a whim cargo. Now, in addition to the wines and brandies that had comprised their original cargo, the hold was stuffed with crates of comfer nuts. Kyle had held forth endlessly on the good price they'd bring, both for the fragrant oil from their kernels for soap and the lovely yellow dye that could be made from their husks. Althea thought that if he crowed once more about the extra profit this would wring from the voyage, she'd throttle him. But self-congratulation was not in the gaze he turned on her. It was cold as seawater, lit with tiny glints of anger.
He neither smiled nor bid her be seated. Instead he simply demanded. "What were you doing in the aft hold?"
Someone had run to the captain and tattled. She kept her voice steady. "I re-stowed the cargo."
"You did."
It was a statement, almost an accusation. But it was not a question, so she did not need to make any answer. Instead, she stood very straight under that piercing gaze. She knew he expected her to babble out explanations and excuses, as Keffria would have. But she was not her sister, nor his wife. He suddenly slammed his palm down on the table before him, and though the sudden impact made her flinch, she still did not speak. She watched him waiting for her to say something, and then felt an odd sense of victory when his temper snapped.
"Did you presume to tell the men to change how that cargo was stowed?"
She spoke very softly, very calmly. "No. I did not. I did the work myself. My father has taught me that aboard a ship, one must see what needs doing, and do it. That is what I have done. I arranged the casks as father would have had them done, were he here. Those casks are now as every shipment of wine has been stowed since I was ten years old, bung up and bilge free, fore and aft, ends wedged off in the wings. They are secure, and if they have not already been spoiled by jostling, they will be marketable when we get to Bingtown."
His cheeks grew pink. Althea wondered how Keffria could stand a man whose cheeks turned pink when he was angry. She braced herself. When Kyle spoke, his voice was not raised, but the longing to shout the words was clear in his clipped accent.
"Your father is not here, Althea. That is precisely the point. I am the master of this vessel, and I gave commands as to how I wanted that cargo stowed. Yet again you have gone behind my back and countermanded those orders. I can't have this interference between me and my crew. You sow discord."
She spoke quietly. "I acted on my own, by myself. I gave the crew no orders at all, nor did I even speak of what I intended to do. I have done nothing to come between you and the crew." She clamped her jaws shut before she could say more. She would not tell him that what stood between him and his crew was his own lack of expertise. The sailors who would have gone to their deaths willingly for her father now spoke openly in the forecastle of finding another vessel when next they shipped out. Kyle was in danger of destroying the hand-picked crew that her father had spent the last decade assembling.
Kyle looked furious that she would contradict him. "It is enough that you went against my orders. That is all it takes to challenge my authority. Your bad example on this ship makes the crew restless. Then I am forced to clamp down the discipline. You should be ashamed for what you bring down on them. But no. You don't care one whit for that. You're above the captain. Althea Vestrit is probably above almighty Sa! You've shown the entire crew your complete disregard for my orders. Were you truly a sailor, I'd make an example of you, one that would prove my orders are the only orders on this ship. But you're nothing but a spoiled merchant's brat. I'll treat you as such, and spare the flesh of your back. But only until you cross me again. Take this warning to heart, girl. I am captain of this vessel, and my word on this ship is law."
Althea did not speak, but neither did she look aside. She met his gaze levelly and kept as much expression off her face as she could. The pink spread to Kyle's forehead. He took a breath and reached for control. He speared her with his eyes. "And what are you, Althea?"
She had not expected such a question. Accusations and rebukes she could deal with silently. But in asking her a question, he demanded an answer, and she knew it would be construed as open defiance. So be it. "I am the owner of this vessel," she said with as much dignity as she could muster.
"Wrong!" This time he did shout. But in an instant he had mastered himself. He leaned forward on the table and near spat the words at her. "You are the daughter of the owner. And even were you the owner, it wouldn't make a whit of difference. It's not the owner who commands the ship, it's the captain. You're not the captain, you're not the mate. You aren't even a proper sailor. All you do is take a stateroom to yourself that should be the second mate's, and do only the chores it suits you to do. The owner of this vessel is Ephron Vestrit, your father. He is the one who gave the Vivacia over to my command. If you cannot respect me for who I am, then respect your father's choice to captain his ship."
"But for my age, he would have made me captain. I know the Vivacia. I should be her captain."
As soon as the words were out of her mouth, Althea regretted them. It was all the opening he had needed, this voicing of what they both knew was true.
"Wrong again. You should be at home, married off to some fancy boy as spoiled as yourself. You haven't the faintest idea of how to captain a vessel. You believe that because your father has allowed you to play at sailoring you know how to command a vessel. You've come to believe you're destined to captain your father's ship. You're wrong. Your father only brought you aboard because he had no sons of his own. He as much as told me so, when Wintrow was born. Were not the Vivacia a liveship, requiring a family member aboard, I'd never have tolerated your pretenses for a moment. But bear this in mind. A member of the Vestrit family is all this ship requires; it needn't be you. If this ship demands a Vestrit aboard her, then she can bear one that has Haven for a surname. My sons share as much of your sister's blood as mine, they're as much Vestrit as Haven. And the next time this ship leaves Bingtown, one of my boys will take your place on her. You'll be left ashore."
Althea could feel she had gone white. The man had no idea what he was saying to her, had no idea of the depth of his threat. It only proved he had no true concept of what a liveship was. He should have never been allowed authority over the Vivacia. If only her father had been well, he would have seen that.
Something of both her despair and defiance must have shown in her face, for Kyle Haven's mouth grew tauter. She wondered if he fought down a smile as he added, "You are confined to your quarters for the remainder of this voyage. And now you are dismissed."
She stood her ground. As well have it out then, now that the lines were drawn. "You have declared that I am not even a sailor aboard this vessel. Very well, then. If that is so, then I am not yours to command. And I have no idea why you fancy that you will command the Vivacia on her next voyage. When we return to Bingtown, I have every expectation that my father will have recovered his health and will resume his command. And hold it, until such time as ship and command are both mine."
He fixed her with a flat stare. "Do you really think so, Althea?"
She puffed up with hatred, believing for an instant that he mocked her faith that her father would recover. But he went on, "Your father's a good captain. And when he hears what you've been up to, countermanding my orders, sowing discord among the men, making mock of me behind my back--"
"Making mock of you?" Althea demanded.
Kyle gave a snort of disdain. "Do you think you can get drunk and witless and throw wild words about Dursay town and not have them come back to me? It only shows what a fool you are."
Althea raced frantically through her scrabbled memories of Dursay. She had got drunk, yes, but only once, and she remembered vaguely that she'd bemoaned her situation to some shipmates. Who? The faces blurred in her memory, but she knew it had been Brashen who'd rebuked her, daring to tell her to shut her hatch and keep private problems private. She did not recall just what she'd said, but now she had a fair idea of who had tattled.
Product details
- Publisher : Spectra (February 2, 1999)
- Language : English
- Mass Market Paperback : 832 pages
- ISBN-10 : 0553575635
- ISBN-13 : 978-0553575637
- Item Weight : 13.6 ounces
- Dimensions : 4.2 x 1.25 x 6.85 inches
- Best Sellers Rank: #488,303 in Books (See Top 100 in Books)
- #6,137 in Action & Adventure Fantasy (Books)
- #9,491 in Paranormal Fantasy Books
- #14,713 in Epic Fantasy (Books)
- Customer Reviews:
About the author

Robin Hobb is a New York Times best-selling fantasy author. She is published in English in the US, UK and Australia, and her works have been widely translated. Her short stories have been finalists for both the Hugo and the Nebula awards, as well as winning the Asimov's Readers Award. Her best known series is The Farseer Trilogy (Assassin's Apprentice, Royal Assassin, and Assassin's Quest.)
Robin Hobb was born in Oakland California, but grew up in Fairbanks, Alaska. She has spent her life mostly in the Pacific Nortwest region of the US, and currently resides in Tacoma, Washington State, with her husband Fred. They have four grown offspring, and six grandchildren.
Robin Hobb is a pen name for Margaret Ogden. She has also written under the name Megan Lindholm.
She published her first short story for children when she was 18,and for some years wrote as a journalist and children's writer. Her stories for children were published in magazines such as Humpty Dumpty's Magazine for Little Children, Jack & Jill and Highlights for Children. She also created educational reading material for children for a programmed reading series by SRA (Science Research Associates.) She received a grant award from the Alaska State Council on the arts for her short story "The Poaching", published in Finding Our Boundaries in 1980.
Fantasy and Science Fiction had always been her two favorite genres, and in the late 70's she began to write in them. Her initial works were published in small press 'fanzines' such as Space and Time (editor Gordon Linzner). Her first professionally published story was "Bones for Dulath" that appeared in the Ace anthology AMAZONS!, edited by Jessica Amanda Salmonson in 1979. A short time later, a second Ki and Vandien story entitled The Small One was published in FANTASTIC in 1980.
During that time period, she and her family had moved from Alaska to Hawaii, and subsequently to Washington State, where they settled. She had various money making occupations (waitress, salesperson, etc.) while striving with her writing. Her husband Fred continued to fish Alaskan waters and was home only about 3 months out of every year. The family lived on a small farm in rural Roy where they raised lots of vegetables, chickens, ducks, geese and other small livestock.
In 1983, her first novel, Harpy's Flight, was published by Ace under the pen name Megan Lindholm. Her later titles under that name included Wizard of the Pigeons, Alien Earth, Luck of the Wheels, and Cloven Hooves.
In 1995, she launched her best selling series of books set in the Realm of the Elderlings. At that time, she began writing as Robin Hobb. Her first trilogy of books were about her popular characters, FitzChivalry Farseer and the Fool. The Farseer Trilogy is comprised of Assassin's Apprentice, Royal Assassin and Assassin's Quest. These books were followed by The Liveship Traders trilogy, set in the same world. The Tawny Man trilogy returned to the tale of Fitz and the Fool. Most recently, the four volumes of the Rain Wilds Chronicles were published: Dragon Keeper, Dragon Haven, City of Dragons and Blood of Dragons.
In 2013, it was announced that she would return to her best-loved characters with a new trilogy, The Fitz and the Fool trilogy. The first volume, Fool's Assassin, will be published in August of 2014.
Other works as Robin Hobb include The Soldier Son trilogy and short stories published in various anthologies. A collection of her shorter works as both Lindholm and Hobb is available in The Inheritance.
She continues to reside in Tacoma, Washington, with frequent visits to the pocket farm in Roy.
Customer reviews
- 5 star4 star3 star2 star1 star5 star64%29%7%0%0%64%
- 5 star4 star3 star2 star1 star4 star64%29%7%0%0%29%
- 5 star4 star3 star2 star1 star3 star64%29%7%0%0%7%
- 5 star4 star3 star2 star1 star2 star64%29%7%0%0%0%
- 5 star4 star3 star2 star1 star1 star64%29%7%0%0%0%
Customer Reviews, including Product Star Ratings help customers to learn more about the product and decide whether it is the right product for them.
To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we don’t use a simple average. Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. It also analyzed reviews to verify trustworthiness.
Learn more how customers reviews work on AmazonCustomers say
Customers find the story captivating and intriguing with interesting twists. They describe the book as incredible and a masterpiece. The characters are well-developed and well-written, with some finding them immature and bittersweet. Readers praise the descriptive writing style and intricate world building. Overall, they find the series engaging and addictive.
AI-generated from the text of customer reviews
Customers find the story engaging with an interesting narrative and well-developed characters. They appreciate the suspenseful plot and well-crafted world. The lore and details of the piratey world are also appreciated. Overall, readers describe the book as one of the best fantasy novels they've read.
"...Science fiction has intelligent spaceships, and maybe some authors have expounded on the personalities of such beings...." Read more
"...The whole system was very intricate and believable. The wizardwood was really intriguing and even though the liveships do kind of have a cheese..." Read more
"...For me, the most impressive aspect of Hobb is her emotional intelligence and grasp of real human nature and human behavior...." Read more
"This trilogy of books is very well written, has an excellent story and most of the characters develop a great deal during the story...." Read more
Customers enjoy the book's readability. They find it engaging and easy to understand, with a nice paperback format. The characters and ship knowledge are well-developed. Readers appreciate the author's work as original and worth reading.
"...I think it is also better and more original. Its distinction is liveships...." Read more
"...nitpicking...but I gave the book four stars and overall it is a really good book...just a few things that maybe will be resolved over the course of..." Read more
"...It felt seamless, and it's a style that effectively immerses the reader...." Read more
"...That’s good. This book shouts “masterpiece”. The story is very deep, with writing that will wake up your brain and your conscience...." Read more
Customers enjoy the character development. They find the characters interesting and well-written. The author is skilled at introducing immature female characters that you start out wanting to strangle. There are no straight-up villains, and each character's story is bittersweet. The traits don't seem artificial, and this series is one of Robin Hobb's best works.
"...What's more, the traits do not seem artificial, inserted so critics will say the characters have color...." Read more
"...as expected by Hobb, but the pacing is good and the protagonists evolve themselves...." Read more
"...Another thing I love about Hobb's fantasy is that there are no straight up villains. Everyone is complex and changeable, and Kennit is no exception...." Read more
"...He’s in some ways the most balanced and relatable of the characters, even if he does share the family penchant for utter stupidity (see below), he..." Read more
Customers enjoy the writing quality of the book. They find the characters well-written and descriptive, with a complex history of Bingtown and the Rain Wilds. The story is deep, with writing that wakes up their brains and consciences. It's a pleasure to read such a well-written tome, and the prose flows smoothly. Readers appreciate the third-person limited style, which they normally prefer.
"...Many characters, including the liveships, display traits that absorb the reader's attention...." Read more
"...For me, the most impressive aspect of Hobb is her emotional intelligence and grasp of real human nature and human behavior...." Read more
"...I should never have feared! This book was brilliantly written and artfully suspenseful, I can’t wait to continue on with the next two books!" Read more
"...aspect of the book was the serpents...it did not go anywhere and was just a muddle...." Read more
Customers find the book engaging with intricate details and vivid descriptions of the world. They appreciate the superb world-building, vivid imagination, and topical themes. The characters are convincingly portrayed, and there is a lot of philosophy and real-life dilemmas.
"...which is unbelievable in our own reality, Hobb's powerful, convincing characterizations open up portals to a believable alternate reality." Read more
"...The world was nice, and I liked the family dynamics and the contract with the Creepy Traders...although Malta was a bore...." Read more
"...The plot and storytelling are beautifully paced. The world-building is done so well that you simply buy into talking wood...." Read more
"...This book was brilliantly written and artfully suspenseful, I can’t wait to continue on with the next two books!" Read more
Customers enjoy the series. They find the trilogy engaging and can't wait for the next book. The fantasy series is enjoyable, with some praising it more than the Fitz saga.
"...one of the best fantasy books I've read but one of the best fiction books I've ever read...." Read more
"...whole-heartedly into this trilogy after finishing Hobb's stellar Farseer series...." Read more
"...This would make a great trilogy to give to a young woman, but be aware that there are adult themes including sex and rape, so perhaps best for a..." Read more
"Hands down Robin Hobb is my favorite fantasy author. I love all her series! Can’t wait for her next book!" Read more
Customers enjoy the era and the unique concept of living ships. They appreciate the details of this piratey world, the tension of things not working out as expected, and the nautical adventures. The book introduces a completely new world of seas with pirates, liveships, traders, and a hint of dragons.
"...Its distinction is liveships. These are sailing ships constructed of wizardwood, and they develop into persons...." Read more
"...The historical period of the setting is captured very well, from the style of dialogue to the expectations of age and gender...." Read more
"...we also have a backstory about the serpents and the origins of live ships. That’s good. This book shouts “masterpiece”...." Read more
"A wonderful world of pirates, liveships, traders, and a hint of dragons.to come. Great read! Can't wait to get into the next book." Read more
Customers have mixed opinions about the pacing. Some find it engaging and fast-paced, with strong character development and quality world building. Others feel the story starts slowly and tediously before picking up pace.
"...more interesting character but we see how damaged he is and how he feels unworthy and cares little for anyone but himself. Kyle is just awful...." Read more
"...There is not so much raw action, as expected by Hobb, but the pacing is good and the protagonists evolve themselves...." Read more
"This book starts off a bit slow for me, and I found the concept of a wooden ship becoming a living being a bit of a stretch as characterized...." Read more
"...to reveal the plot but what I can say is that I was very quickly enthralled by this book...." Read more
Reviews with images

came as advertised
Top reviews from the United States
There was a problem filtering reviews. Please reload the page.
- Reviewed in the United States on June 13, 2012This is a review of Robin Hobb's THE LIVESHIP TRADERS trilogy. The trilogy comprises one story, 2448 pages in three mass-paperback, and you may ask, "Do I really want to devote that much time?" What with so much other, EASIER media--TV, movies, video games, computers, and music--you might shy away from such a commitment. But when you discipline yourself to read, you channel your mind with more focus than you can with any other medium. If you never read, you are forever just a dabbler, never penetrating the depths of truth for hidden treasures. And if you avoid fiction, telling yourself that you do not need it and that it is trivial, then your awareness is parochial. You remain blind to the realities, the characters, and the events of alternate universes.
I bought and read the Spectra mass-paperback editions: SHIP OF MAGIC (1999, 809 pages), MAD SHIP (2000, 850 pages), and SHIP OF DESTINY (2001, 789 pages). Even so, I recommend the Spectra hardcover editions because I find thick paperbacks less convenient while reading. I do not recommend the Harper Voyager paperbacks, whose cover art is drab.
Though Hobb's FARSEER TRILOGY was published first and occurs on the same world, THE LIVESHIP TRADERS trilogy is self-contained. I think it is also better and more original. Its distinction is liveships. These are sailing ships constructed of wizardwood, and they develop into persons. Science fiction has intelligent spaceships, and maybe some authors have expounded on the personalities of such beings. And though fantasy has other examples of sailing ships with personalities, I do not know of any fantasy authors who dramatize the theme as well as Hobb does here.
Which reminds me of Hobb's forte, at least in THE LIVESHIP TRADERS. That is her characterizations. Many characters, including the liveships, display traits that absorb the reader's attention. What's more, the traits do not seem artificial, inserted so critics will say the characters have color. Behavior and complex personalities blend logically into the story, evolving as the story progresses. Certainly this is a tale of high-seas adventure, human relationships, politics, magic, and action. Yet despite the presence of magic, which is unbelievable in our own reality, Hobb's powerful, convincing characterizations open up portals to a believable alternate reality.
- Reviewed in the United States on April 15, 2009This is my first Hobb book. I tried Farseer but I couldn't get into it. I thought I'd give her another try since so many people seem to like her so much. I'm glad I did, and I'll have to give Farseer another try.
Possibly spoilers here...
First the good stuff. The magic was really kool. The whole system was very intricate and believable. The wizardwood was really intriguing and even though the liveships do kind of have a cheese factor, I still liked it. The story was really a pageturner, I looked forward to picking up the book everyday ( I read it on breaks at work mostly). A lot of the characters broke out of the stereotypes of pirates and such although Althea...I dunno she kind of seemed too much the spunky heroine ya know? I liked her and all...but she wasn't the most interesting of the bunch. The most I liked her was when she did something I didn't expect, which was only a couple times...the plot point of her dressing up as a boy could be seen a mile away. But it doesn't put a damper on it, I think she still has potential in the rest of the story esp with Brashen. I also liked her thing with the woodworking girl Amber...which wasn't as much as I wish it would have been. The world was nice, and I liked the family dynamics and the contract with the Creepy Traders...although Malta was a bore. Kyle...who can say why Ephrom ever trusted him for a moment?
Now for some of the not so good stuff...
Paragon...I don't know, he was interesting but just a bit too blank sometimes characterwise. I can see why that could be since he lost his memories...but some of the stuff with him and Amber I didn't think added much to the story.
Interminable setting details...could have been A LOT shorter and tighter if some of that stuff was left out.
While I really liked Kennit and his whore...I wish there were more background information about what made him the way he is...hopefully that will be brought out in the next two books...but I would have liked more in this one! It would have made him less of just a villain.
Wintrow...was interesting and everything it's just I didn't find myself liking him very much at all. That's not all bad...I realize not every character has to be likable...but I had to read a lot about him and I thought he was spiteful and pompous...but I do see room for him to grow and I hope he does
I think the worst aspect of the book was the serpents...it did not go anywhere and was just a muddle. I know we'll see more...but bring it somewhere in the first book!
Most of this stuff is probably nitpicking...but I gave the book four stars and overall it is a really good book...just a few things that maybe will be resolved over the course of the trilogy but I wished were brought to a better tantalizing crescendo in the first book.
Happy reading!
Top reviews from other countries
- The Chatty OneReviewed in Canada on April 9, 2024
5.0 out of 5 stars A wilder ride than I was expecting.
I came into Robin Hobb's worlds through her original Assassin's trilogy which was very good but had a sort of epic slow burn pace that felt a differ from my usual reading habits.
That's not the case here. The story starts and pulls you into new adventures in the same world but to the south of the 6 Duchies. In a realm of seafaring, trade, old families, intrigue and change. I love the concept of these magical ships (I'm not spoiling things here, the name of the book does it already) and the characters attached to them.
Great story, great characters that pull your emotions this way and that. I'm engrossed in this series and am currently reading the second one. Can't wait.
-
Kerstin R.Reviewed in Germany on December 28, 2024
5.0 out of 5 stars Eine wunderschöne Fantasyreihe in 3 Bänden
Die Geschichte ist packend und originell. Habe mir bereits Band 2 und 3 bestellt. Für Ungduldige nicht unbedingt zu empfehlen, da Robin Hobb sehr genau über jedes Detail etwas zu erzählen weiß! Auf jeden Fall für alle Fantasy-Leseratten zu empfehlen.
- sana-bReviewed in the United Kingdom on September 18, 2024
5.0 out of 5 stars Really good read
These books by Robin Hobb are easy to read I got captured in the weaving of the story. Hard to put down
- SidhinReviewed in India on August 1, 2023
5.0 out of 5 stars Had even more fun than farseer triology
After reading the Farseer triology, I just wanted more of Fitz and his adventure, so I was skeptical about reading a totally orthogonal story in the realm. I am glad I listened to advise online not to skip the live ship traders. This series is just another masterpiece. The characters are all so well thought out. Robin Hobb knows how to develop a character through the story.
The character journey portrayed here is the spine of the story, from Kennit to Malta, to Althea or Brashan. Add that to the intricately thought out world. I can't wait to gobble up rest of the books in the Elderling Saga.
-
DevelinReviewed in Spain on February 7, 2023
5.0 out of 5 stars Estupendo. Un gran libro para abrir esta trilogia
Hace mucho que no cogia un libro que no puedo dejar de leer. Es de esos que lo devoras por simple placer de lectura. Llevo ya 10 anos esperando por el tercer libro de The Name of wind, el siguiente de The Gentleman Bastards, ya para no hablar de The Winds of Winter, que R.R. Martin sigue comiendo hamburguesas pero poco escribir, con todo esta espera me puse a leer muchas cosas buenas pero ya hace anos que no uno tan bueno como Ships of Magic. Hace muchos anos devoré Assassins Quest de la misma autora pero este me parece mejor.